The Price of Coalition

Subjugation to the Human Rights Act and the European Convention on Human Rights, and the consequent release of Abu Qatada, is part of the price we pay the Liberal Democrats for the votes of their MPs in the House of Commons.

Last week at Prime Minister’s Questions, David Cameron raised the intriguing possibility that we may not need to pay that price much longer. He noted that Labour “even support our police commissioners so strongly that droves of Labour MPs are going to quit to try to become them”.

Yesterday I followed up, asking the Home Secretary “We cannot currently repeal the Human Rights Act because the Liberal Democrats will not let us. However, so many Labour Members are running in the police elections that, come November—if they all win—it is possible that we may have a Conservative-Democratic Unionist party majority. Will we use it?” 

If even a few Labour MPs step down to become police commissioners, or big city mayors with Gisela Stuart and Peter Ainsworth for example keen to run for Birmingham and Coventry, it would be a crucial development because the current parliamentary arithmetic that makes us dependant on the Liberal Democrats is so tight.

Current House of Commons

Con 305                Lab 256    SNP 6   Lab ‘rainbow’ allies 9

DUP 8                    LD 57                (PC 3 + SDLP 3 + NI Other 2 + Green 1)

= 313                     =313                                     

(Sinn Fein and Deputy Speakers excluded)

Fear that Labour could cobble together a ‘rainbow’ coalition with the Liberal Democrats and several minor parties (although not the SNP) caused us to offer the Liberal Democrats concessions for a coalition which included no action on the EU or the Human Rights Act / ECHR.

If three or more Labour MPs step down in November, or just one if a Conservative MP were by then to have replaced Chris Huhne in Eastleigh, then the putative Labour, Liberal Democrat and ‘rainbow’ alliance would not have the votes to win a confidence vote in the Commons.

We could embark on repeal of the Human Rights Act and an EU referendum/repatriation and, if needed, force an election under the Fixed Term Parliaments Act whether Ed Miliband and the Liberal Democrats liked it or not.



Filed under david cameron, Home Affairs Select Committee, Human Rights Act, labour, lib dems, mark reckless, rochester and strood, theresa may

2 responses to “The Price of Coalition

  1. Dan

    But you know that not all Tory MPs want an EU referendum and to leave the ECHR. Not least the member for Witney.

  2. Referendum/Democracy?

    “We could embark on repeal of the Human Rights Act and an EU referendum/repatriation”

    If the ’81’ had real conviction and threatened an immediate mass resignation we could have our referendum immediately. Do you really believe what you say or are you just distracting the masses with talk whilst the EU disaster rumbles on?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s